I think it's so great that you're getting these words out there, Julie. And re tough subject matter: tough for you to write, I mean. I'm looking forward to reading the book. Much love, as always. 😘
Let the title come to you at the end, after you have written the entire piece and re-read it a few times. There is always something that shines through for the right title. Trust the process. XO Tracy
Thank you Julie for today’s sharing. I “heard” work-in-progress in your remarks. Not unlike the human condition.
Rumi, whose thoughts and writings reach us from the 13th century, have given me opportunities for deep thought/contemplation over the last 20 years. One such notion of his is to welcome turbulence or grief into our homes. He advised us to see such events as essential parts of our lives.
(Note: I’m neither compensated for my dithering nor trying to sell you on his world views.)
In current form your working title, to me, conveys the emotional gut punch that such events deliver. Unbidden; unwelcome. Practice your best self care as you go forward.
Thank you, Gary. I appreciate your thoughts and kindness. I too would be curious a Rumi book you recommend. I've read...Rumi's Little Book of Wisdom, what would you add? Thank you.
Hi Julie, I’ve always resonated with Rumi saying, “Out beyond wrongdoing and right doing, there is a field. I’ll meet you there.” The feeling of warmth and kindness is immediate.
You may already have seen my reply to Clark Rose’s similar question. I can complicate matters sometimes. 😔 Beth and I had the good fortune to attend a local performance featuring Coleman Barks narrating The Flowing Waters Tour. I’ve yet to score a hit on that title in my searches. The performance consisted of two whirling dervishes, wind instruments (bassoon? Piccolo?), and a percussionist that played a tambourine so amazingly that it appeared mostly as a blur!
As this was to promote “The Illuminated Rumi,” we obtained a copy signed by Coleman Barks. He seemed to radiate energy the entire evening. The venue was named The Moon. 🌕
Look what I just found! By accident, not effort...
Thanks for your question. I’ll quickly point out the tension that exists between Persian scholars who also interpret ancient Persian from Rumi’s era versus scholars like Coleman Barks in the US that claim to be translators. At best other valid translators may be referenced but not in a position to review/critique works by Barks.
With that caution I have to confess ownership of two publications by Barks. A daily reader titled A Year With Rumi and The Illuminated Rumi. The former is disjointed by its nature as a daily reader. The latter is a visual and literary delight, containing illustrations by Michael Green of spiritually based images across time. This also serves as a history of Rumi’s life, influences, and contributions. I don’t own “The Essential Rumi” (Barks, again). It appears to focus on Rumi’s works.
My apologies for a less than straightforward reply to your request. The devil is in the details... or perhaps there is no devil.
A word of caution: I’m a replier with a skill to make replies (mine) disappear! After I acknowledged Clark’s question, I began a direct reply to you. Then, poof! Gone. If none of that made its way to you, perhaps at the core was my wife, Beth, and I seeing a fascinating performance by Coleman and an entourage of others performing while he recited Rumi.
Notwithstanding the rightful Persian assertions over authorship, the evening was delightful.
That’s where we obtained The Illuminated Rumi as the event was a promotional one for his new book. I’m grateful that a couple brain cells have preserved that memory.
Thank you for sharing all this with us! I admire your courage and faith! I know the end is good, and that is encouraging me as I pray for some close friends who are going through this right now. Like I prayed for Jeff! I know prayer is powerful. I know God is good. I know He wants us to pray, and it gives me something to do for the people I love ❤️
Thank you Claudette! Yes God is faithful and I also believe in the power of prayer. He answered so many prayers during last years challenge. Your friends are blessed to have you in their life. Please let me know how I can pray for you during this season. Hugs to you and yours.
This is going to be good Julie! I feel it. It's real, raw and powerful and I already feel emotionally invested. Take tender care of you as you write (and no doubt recall these times). x
Your writing is so beautiful, even though the subject is tough. Terrific work, Julie. 🙌
Thank you so much Rebecca. I appreciate you reading along even though it is a tough one.
I think it's so great that you're getting these words out there, Julie. And re tough subject matter: tough for you to write, I mean. I'm looking forward to reading the book. Much love, as always. 😘
Thank you so much Rebecca and hope to see your smiling face again soon! :)
Hope to join you soon! 😊😊😊
Oh great! We look forward to seeing you again.
Let the title come to you at the end, after you have written the entire piece and re-read it a few times. There is always something that shines through for the right title. Trust the process. XO Tracy
Thank you Tracy. I needed this reminder...trust the process. Thanks again and enjoy your bling! :)
Thank you Julie for today’s sharing. I “heard” work-in-progress in your remarks. Not unlike the human condition.
Rumi, whose thoughts and writings reach us from the 13th century, have given me opportunities for deep thought/contemplation over the last 20 years. One such notion of his is to welcome turbulence or grief into our homes. He advised us to see such events as essential parts of our lives.
(Note: I’m neither compensated for my dithering nor trying to sell you on his world views.)
In current form your working title, to me, conveys the emotional gut punch that such events deliver. Unbidden; unwelcome. Practice your best self care as you go forward.
Thank you, Gary. I appreciate your thoughts and kindness. I too would be curious a Rumi book you recommend. I've read...Rumi's Little Book of Wisdom, what would you add? Thank you.
Hi Julie, I’ve always resonated with Rumi saying, “Out beyond wrongdoing and right doing, there is a field. I’ll meet you there.” The feeling of warmth and kindness is immediate.
You may already have seen my reply to Clark Rose’s similar question. I can complicate matters sometimes. 😔 Beth and I had the good fortune to attend a local performance featuring Coleman Barks narrating The Flowing Waters Tour. I’ve yet to score a hit on that title in my searches. The performance consisted of two whirling dervishes, wind instruments (bassoon? Piccolo?), and a percussionist that played a tambourine so amazingly that it appeared mostly as a blur!
As this was to promote “The Illuminated Rumi,” we obtained a copy signed by Coleman Barks. He seemed to radiate energy the entire evening. The venue was named The Moon. 🌕
Look what I just found! By accident, not effort...
I love this Rumi saying. I appreciate you sharing your experiences with us. WOW! This performance sounds amazing. Thank you Gary.
Every time I read anything “Rumi” I am awestruck. Please recommend one of the many Rumi books out there. Thanks Gary…
Thanks for your question. I’ll quickly point out the tension that exists between Persian scholars who also interpret ancient Persian from Rumi’s era versus scholars like Coleman Barks in the US that claim to be translators. At best other valid translators may be referenced but not in a position to review/critique works by Barks.
With that caution I have to confess ownership of two publications by Barks. A daily reader titled A Year With Rumi and The Illuminated Rumi. The former is disjointed by its nature as a daily reader. The latter is a visual and literary delight, containing illustrations by Michael Green of spiritually based images across time. This also serves as a history of Rumi’s life, influences, and contributions. I don’t own “The Essential Rumi” (Barks, again). It appears to focus on Rumi’s works.
My apologies for a less than straightforward reply to your request. The devil is in the details... or perhaps there is no devil.
Thank you Gary!
A word of caution: I’m a replier with a skill to make replies (mine) disappear! After I acknowledged Clark’s question, I began a direct reply to you. Then, poof! Gone. If none of that made its way to you, perhaps at the core was my wife, Beth, and I seeing a fascinating performance by Coleman and an entourage of others performing while he recited Rumi.
Notwithstanding the rightful Persian assertions over authorship, the evening was delightful.
That’s where we obtained The Illuminated Rumi as the event was a promotional one for his new book. I’m grateful that a couple brain cells have preserved that memory.
Thanks for the scholarly response. Much appreciated Gary. I look forward to feasting on Rumi.
Thank you for sharing all this with us! I admire your courage and faith! I know the end is good, and that is encouraging me as I pray for some close friends who are going through this right now. Like I prayed for Jeff! I know prayer is powerful. I know God is good. I know He wants us to pray, and it gives me something to do for the people I love ❤️
Thank you Claudette! Yes God is faithful and I also believe in the power of prayer. He answered so many prayers during last years challenge. Your friends are blessed to have you in their life. Please let me know how I can pray for you during this season. Hugs to you and yours.
Editing is tough
The past becomes the present
Protect yourself Jules..
I agree with Kym. Compelling...
Indeed...every line I resonate with. Thank you Clark.
I like it. It’s spare and to the point. And emotionally powerful
Thank you Kym for your thoughts and support. Drip by drip...
This is going to be good Julie! I feel it. It's real, raw and powerful and I already feel emotionally invested. Take tender care of you as you write (and no doubt recall these times). x
Hi Georgia, Thank you so much for reading and your thoughts. This is so helpful! I appreciate your kindness.
Take good care, Julie
I like this too!! Can't wait to read your book!!
Thank you so much Faith. I hope your week is off to a great start. :)
Thank you for sharing as you go Julie.
I can’t remember “the telling” about my lump. I suspect that’s because I was ignoring it... and telling myself it was something it was not. 🤔
Thank you Gail. I'm sure my husband can relate...he wanted to believe it was something else.